Handling overdispersion with negative binomial and generalized poisson regression models to incorporate covariates and to ensure nonnegativity, the mean or the fitted value is assumed to be multiplicative, i. Generalized poisson regression is commonly applied to overdispersed count data, and focused on modelling the conditional mean of the response. Which is the most appropriate method to analyze counts. Stata module to detect overdispersion in countdata. We consider instead a hierarchical approach to quantile regression of overdispersed. Modelling a poisson distribution with overdispersion. Variable selection for zeroinflated and overdispersed. The variance of daysabs is nearly 10 times larger than the mean. Regression based on the double poisson distribution proposed by efron 1986. As an example, suppose we examine the impact of the median. I would suggest you read the earlier posts on the similar topics by googling your problems plus stata like count data stata or poisson models stata and surely without the paranthesis, which will search out a complete discussions using stata for you. Overdispersionexcess zeros and negative binomial panel for crime data 21 feb 2016, 18.
Thus, overdisp can be implementd without the necessity of previously estimating poisson or binomial negative models. I dont know whether that can be encapsulated in a single test or figure of merit, if that is what you seek. Overdispersed poisson data are discussed, for example, in breslow 1984 and lawless 1987. The distribution of daysabs is displaying signs of overdispersion, that is, greater variance than might be expected in a poisson distribution. The over dispersed poisson and negative binomial models have different variance functions.
At the present, im modelling this overdispersion using something like the following code in r. In addition to this, is there any minimum number of observations required to do check the fit of the poisson distribution. Understated standard errors can lead to erroneous conclusions. There is software in r, stata, and limdep for the above models, and others. This paper presents an em algorithm for maximum likelihood estimation in generalized linear models with overdispersion. An alternative approach is to fit a poisson model and use the robust or sandwich estimator of the standard errors. Actually, when modeling it is probably best to start with poisson and if found to be overdispersed then use the nb. One of the methods is known as scaling the standard errors. Overdispersionexcess zeros and negative binomial panel. And if you go another layer doing a poisson on the result of that second poisson but modeling it as a straight poisson you get a. Stata module to estimate negative binomial regression. So i think a normal poisson model cannot be fitted and i need to use an over dispersed. Testing for overdispersion in poisson and binomial regression models c. How to produce a graph of predicted values versus observed.
The contamination model would be assumed to apply for a small subpopulation, with small prior probability. By mixing a poisson process with a gamma distribution for the poisson parameter, for example, the negative binomial distribution results, which is thus overdispersed relative to the poisson. Joe and zhu 2005 show that the generalized poisson distribution can also be motivated as a poisson mixture and hence provides an alternative to the. However, conditional mean regression models may be sensitive to response outliers and provide no information on other conditional distribution features of the response. However, the overdispersed poisson was a tricky one since i had. Stata has several procedures that can be used in analyzing count data. Here we introduce the gencco command to reshape datasets from timeseries to timestratified casecrossover designs. Negative binomial likelihood fits for overdispersed count.
You will need to use the glm command to obtain the residuals to check other assumptions of the poisson model see cameron and trivedi 1998 and dupont 2002 for more information. The wikipedia pages for almost all probability distributions are excellent and very comprehensive see, for instance, the page on the normal distribution. Running an overdispersed poisson model will generate understated standard errors. There are also other software solutions for statistical packages like iveware for sas or ice for stata that support basic count data imputation procedures. This overdispersion is not apparent in a conditional logistic analysis because in each casecontrol set in the expanded data outcomes are binary 0 or 1 for which overdispersion has no meaning. The purpose of this session is to show you how to use stata s procedures for count models including poisson, negative binomial zero inflated poisson, and zero inflated negative binomial regression. For overdispersed count regression, in particular, an contamination approach might involve negative binomial or poisson lognormal representations, and specify a main model and contamination model. What should i do if stata can not show the result of nb. Go back to example 1, but with count data and overdispersed poisson regression.
In stata, a poisson model can be estimated via glm command with the log link and the poisson family. Testing for overdispersion in poisson and binomial. The tests are designed to be powerful against arbitrary alternative mixture models where only the first two moments of the mixed distribution are. Analysis of timestratified casecrossover studies in.
Regression models for count data based on the double poisson distribution. Then we will discuss alternative statistical models to perform casecrossover analysis for aggregated data using poisson and overdispersed poisson regression poisson and glm and conditional poisson regression xtpoisson. This usually gives results very similar to the overdispersed poisson model. The original event counts may have variation greater than that predicted by a poisson distribution, so be overdispersed in a poisson model. The poisson model can be applied to the count of events occurring within a specific time period. Poisson regression stata data analysis examples idre stats. Sasstat bayesian hierarchical poisson regression model. For example, poisson regression analysis is commonly used to model count data. But if you have it be hierarchical one time with a poisson on the poisson but model it as a straight poisson you get a dispersion estimate about 2.
Through innovative analytics, business intelligence and data management software and services, sas helps customers at more than 75,000 sites make better decisions faster. Glm in r negative binomial regression v poisson regression. More general discussions of overdispersion are also to be found in. Poisson negative binomial and make the dependent variable homicides instead and consider a zero inflated model. It can occur due to extra populationheterogeneity, omission of key predictors, and outliers. The algorithm is initially derived as a form of gaussian quadrature assuming a normal mixing distribution, but with only slight variation it can be used for a completely unknown mixing distribution, giving a straightforward method for the fully nonparametric ml.
The relevant r code can be retrieved from the supplementary material section of this article. The quasi poisson model and negative binomial model can account for overdispersion, and both have two parameters. Negative binomial regression can be used for overdispersed count data, that is. If you are using glm in r, and want to refit the model adjusting for overdispersion one way of doing it is to use summary.
Dean in this article a method for obtaining tests for overdispersion with respect to a natural exponential family is derived. Analyzing overdispersed count data with proc fmm youtube. My initial understanding was that i should use poisson, unless the data were overdispersed. The overdispersed poisson and negative binomial models have different variance functions. Before we get to an alternative analysis, lets run a poisson regression. This example uses the random statement in mcmc procedure to fit a bayesian hierarchical poisson regression model to overdispersed count data. Stata software developed for estimation of double poisson. Hurdle models based on the zerotruncated poisson lognormal distribu. Regression models for count data based on the double.
In this model, the count variable is believed to be generated by a poisson. However, more advanced models like zeroin ation models or multilevel count data models are currently not supported. On april 23, 2014, statalist moved from an email list to a forum, based at. However, the poisson and binomial models remain valid in many instances and, because of their simplicity and appeal, it is of real interest to ascertain when they apply. Alternative count models a common more general model is the negative binomial model. The poisson distribution has one free parameter and does not allow for the variance to be adjusted independently of the mean.
Overdispersed counts since counts are free to vary over the integers, they obviously can show a variance that is either substantially greater or less than their mean, and thereby show overdispersion or underdispersion relative to what is speci ed by the poisson model. I have a data set that id expect to follow a poisson distribution, but it is overdispersed by about 3fold. This paper develops a unifying theory for testing for overdispersion and generalizes tests previously derived, including those by fisher 1950, collings and margolin 1985. Variable selection for zeroinflated and overdispersed data with application to health care demand in germany. If the test significantly rejects the null hypothesis then it would imply that the mean is significantly different from variance and hence doesnt follow the poisson distribution. We now fit a negative binomial model with the same predictors. The choice of a distribution from the poisson family is often dictated by the nature of the empirical data. Handling overdispersion with negative binomial and. But how to check whether there is overdispersion from r and s. Predictors of the number of awards earned include the type of program in. The main feature of the poisson model is the assumption that the mean and variance of the count data are equal.
This is not the way to check for possible overdispersion. In this module, students will become familiar with negative binomial likelihood fits for overdispersed count data. Ye sun, run the poisson model using the glm command, checking the value of the. The stata logs show an example from long 1990, involving the number of publications produced by ph. For example, examine observed and fitted for both models. It should be easy enough to check whether a negative binomial model gives. Regressionbased tests for overdispersion in the poisson. Estimation of hurdle models for overdispersed count data. It should be easy enough to check whether a negative binomial model gives much better fit to the data than a poisson model. For example fit the model using glm and save the object as result. A general maximum likelihood analysis of overdispersion in.
Modeling underdispersed count data with generalized poisson. Unless properly handled, this can lead to invalid inf. A number of excellent text books provide methods of eliminating or reducing the overdispersion of the data. We also show how to do various tests for overdispersion and for discriminating between models.
904 1477 1445 226 1419 1165 671 1519 66 59 872 1039 693 582 43 701 1147 1544 111 327 878 873 94 715 970 501 478 1242 456 488 776